The Creativity
Core
  • Introduction
  • Alumni Testimonials
  • The Blog
  • Art Gallery
    • Mind Maps for Teachers
  • Contact
  • The Books
  • Student Samples
    • Poetry
    • On-Line Portfolios
    • Memoirs

Penny Kittle, New Goals, and The Summer Reading Assignment

6/16/2013

4 Comments

 

Flipping Summer Reading: 
    Students Decide, Teachers Listen


Click on photos to enlarge them or discover a link.

PictureClick to download!
Last week the English Department rolled out a new concept in Summer Reading. 

Instead of demanding that students read a classic (or two) while preparing for September's in-class essay, we are simply encouraging our students to read throughout the summer and to record what they've accomplished.

By inverting the old way into something new and radical, we are really flipping the classroom -- no at-home videos needed! 

The students will choose their own reading and decide how to respond to it. There is no double-entry journal, no mandatory essay, no disincentive to get in the way of students' relationships with their books. We are trying to develop a love of reading by backing off and creating space.


Picture
School in September will begin without the teachers and their students rushing through the dreaded Summer Reading essay.

We are giving our pupils room to make their own decisions. By simply encouraging them and helping them "set goals & deadlines" we have placed ourselves in the positions of literary coaches rather than assignment taskmasters.


Picture
This new assignment is UNGRADED, and will help both students and teachers because now kids can't show up on the first day of school already behind in your class, already doing poorly on the first essay.

Plus, it gives us time to teach our writing lessons and demonstrate the level of discourse expected in our classes before we administer the first assessments.



Stated Goals of Assignment:

Picture
  •    Encourage a lifelong habit of reading.
  •    Push our students to read more advanced and more complex material.
  •    Discover what our students are reading.
  • Ignite the literary conversation among students & between teachers and students.


PictureA student's website: summer-reading goals.
This is a dramatic change from the old assignments I've given students over the summer, and I love it! 

Of course I love it -- I designed it:)!

I've always been concerned with how reading assignments can provoke students into hating reading.  Why should Summer Reading -- of all assignments! -- continue to teach our students that READING means dragging yourself through a book you don't find appealing, don't want to start, and might never actually read anyway?

Many of my colleagues in the English Department feel similarly, and they responded positively when I showed them my concept for a new assignment.

We are abandoning an old trope: the September essay on summer reading. In its place we hope to develop a lifelong habit of reading what interests YOU! 


The idea for this Summer Reading Assignment was inspired by Penny Kittle's presentation at last Fall's NCTE Conference in Las Vegas.

Picture
Picture
I've always thought Kittle was gutsy, wise, and creative. I like everything she has to say about teaching reading and writing. I circled her name in the catalog months before the conference.

Picture
My notes from Kittle's session include her idea for applying goal-setting strategies. Ask your students to put their goals in writing by keeping a list: "What am I going to read next?" 

Goal-setting is such a simple and effective technique, and yet it is easily and often overlooked.


If you want to check out more by the fabulous Penny Kittle, click here.


Picture
If the new Summer Reading assignment is going to be successful, it is important for teachers to lead their classes through goal-setting sessions in the waning days of June.

Many of us saw students engage in passionate and enthusiastic conversation about the literature they have read or hope to read.


Picture
I spent one period having the students create mind maps and lists of books they'd read the past few years.

After ten minutes of brainstorming, we did a whip around the room. During the whip each student had to suggest a book to the class.

I typed up this list on screen in real-time as they explained their suggestions.

It was so much fun! And it was an inspirational, informational, student-centered lesson about reading.

If I hadn't been with my AP class, I would have given more support to my students. Example:  A period in the "book museum" having our excellent librarians lead them through a showcase of new literature to choose. Librarians are so good at getting kids excited to read -- I love to collaborate with them.

We did set up support on the English Department website: links, lists, etc. have been posted here.


What about the Common Core?

Picture
I believe this new assignment is perfectly Common Core Ready!

The photo to the left is a slice of the CC Requirements in Reading Literature: it's all about "analyzing" and "determining."

First, kids have to determine what they want to read! They need room to do their own analyses. 

The only teaching needed in July and August is to encourage young minds to explore on their own. There will be plenty of time during the school year to teach them the proper writing skills in order to explain what they've "determined" about literature and how to "analyze" it. 


Picture
The Common Core does not mandate certain books, and it does not require that a single novel be taught to an entire class. It embraces student choice, diversity, and autonomy in the reading decisions made by our students.

Notice standard 10.10 to the right: "blah blah ... INDEPENDENTLY and blah blah..."

The CCR wants students to "grapple with works of exceptional craft ..." while being led up a "staircase of complexity."

How can that staircase begin with a high-level text mandated over the summer WITHOUT the support of a teacher or a classroom environment?


Picture
The ground-base for reading instruction is to instill a love for literature and build a skill-set for reading. 

Will some students not read over the summer? Sure! And how is that any different from past practices and results?

As my colleague Mr. Graham likes to say: "Summer reading ... Summer not!" 
With our new assignment, we have our best chance to light the literary fire even beneath our most difficult pupils.
                                                *****
P.S. Our AP and Honors classes must complete the traditional reading/writing task about a classic ... AND this assignment.


Endnote: Students really do enjoy reading!

Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture

4 Comments
Pamela Hunnisett link
6/17/2013 12:42:55 pm

Bravo! I LOVE your enthusiasm and approach and intend to share your re-visioning with my department! Hail the Kittle!

Reply
Daniel Weinstein
6/17/2013 11:35:38 pm

Thank you Pamela! Yes, hail the Kittle!

Reply
giggi ellison
7/1/2013 01:49:16 pm

My kids are 6 - 7 - 8th

The ideas are creative and I feel hopeful.

This year I couldn't face Atticus Finch one more time, despite the handy dandy websites available - did autobiographies - students - instead. The portfolios are utterly amazing. Thank you!

Reply
Sarah link
7/2/2014 06:45:42 am

Great idea for a summer project that should really get kids reading! I'm a Kittle fan myself, and the ideas I have gotten from her books have helped me, and my students, immensely. Now if only I could get my school to let me get rid of the "September essay"! Congrats to you and your department for making independent reading and CHOICE a priority.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Blog Author:
    Daniel Weinstein

    I teach AP Language and Creative Writing at Great Neck South High School on Long Island. 

    Teaching philosophies: Student-centered. Collaborative. Goal-setting. Coaching. Divergent thinking. Portfolio. Writing as therapy. Take Risks! Find your voice. Experiment! Freewrite. Poetry. Memoir. Editing. Layers. Deadlines. Frontload. Rap and hip-hop. Expository technique. Drawing. Art. Magic Markers. Mind Maps. Publishing. Music. Cellphones. Ipods. Wikipedia. Twitter. Facebook. Stay modern. Stay open-minded. Keep learning. 

    RSS Feed

    Blog Entries

    All
    01. The Call For Creativity
    02. Take Risks!
    03. Use Color!
    04. Set Goals & Deadlines
    05. Teaching Rap Music
    06. Common Core
    07. Notice & Note + Mind Maps = Improved Reading Lessons
    08. Open-Notes Exams
    09. The Essay: A Multi Step Approach
    10. Proposal Accepted
    11. The Facebook Group
    12. Portfolios
    13. Summer Reading
    14. Creative ID Cards
    15. Student Choice In Literature
    16. Mind Maps Across The Curriculum
    17. NCTE 2013: My Presentation
    18. Quarter's End: Calculate & Reflect
    19. Mind Maps Magazine - Feature Story!
    20. Revising The MM Lesson
    21. Free Lesson: Ab Art
    22. Heinemann Reprint
    23. Student Videos
    24. NCTE 2014
    25. MM For Identity: Heinemnn Reprint
    26: Guest Columnist: Radhika
    27: Moving Past Mind Maps
    28. Improving Literacy
    29. Reading Comps
    30. Professional Development
    31. Reading Workshop
    32. Hybrid Success

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

© 2013 Daniel Weinstein
Contact to schedule a presentation or workshop.